Finding small, fast-moving and nocturnal mammals in trees was never going to be easy. As a result of competition, social factors and predators, bats move between trees every few days. Odds are, on any given day, there is a 5% chance of bats being home when you visit. To put it another way, there is a 95% chance you will fail.

Tree survey guidance
Historically, industry guidance recommended surveyors assess a tree’s suitability. This involved assigning one of four categories:
· High – suitable for maternity or winter use.
· Moderate – suitable for individuals or small groups, for an extended time-period.
· Low – suitable for individuals, short-term use only.
· Negligible – unsuitable for bats.
Based on the category, the tree would receive a diminishing survey effort from; 3 visits (high) to 0 visits (negligible). These surveys were to be undertaken between April and September, although May to August was favoured. Within these constraints, survey dates were picked at random.
Our research has highlighted the inadequacies of this approach. I have presented the results to multiple audiences, including at the National Bat Conference (if you missed it you can catch up here).
Something needed to change. So with the publication of the 4th Edition of the Bat Conservation Trust’s survey guidance, I was interested to see how we move this challenging field forward.

What has changed?
- Subjective assessments are out
The big change is the move away from subjective assessments of potential roost features (PRF). Instead, surveyors will apply an objective test, primarily based on size:
- PRF-M – the feature is suitable for multiple bats or
- PRF-I – the feature is suitable for one bat (or a very small number of bats)

If this categorisation system sounds familiar, you are not alone. To me, the new objective assessment is functionally the same as the old subjective test, except the moderate and low categories have been combined:
- High is now PRF-M
- Moderate and low are now PRF-I
So, has anything actually changed? Well yes, survey effort has been reduced.
- Surveys are only required where a maternity roost may be present
Tree features which are only suitable for individual bats now receive no additional survey. For these smaller features, it is recommended that appropriate compensation is provided in absence of surveys. However, this begs the question; how do you determine what is ‘appropriate compensation’ when you don’t know what bats are using it.

What hasn’t changed?
Perhaps as frustrating as the above, are the things that haven’t changed.
- Bias towards summer surveys
There has always been a bias towards summer surveys. This, understandably, originates from when survey options were limited to emergence/re-entry surveys. However, aerial tree inspections are now commonplace.
The Bat Tree Habitat Key co-ordinated the the collation of a bats and trees database. This provides the evidence (if it was needed) that bats use trees in all months of the year. In fact, species spend all year in trees. If we are not surveying trees in the winter, how can we expect to find hibernating bats?

- Random timing of surveys
Within the constraints of May to September, surveyors are required to pick random dates – spaced at least three weeks apart. At best, precise dates of surveys are based on the surveyor’s subjective assessment and, at worst, based on project timescales.
This is despite the Bat Tree Habitat Key database providing the following evidence:
- Which Potential Roost Features are used during each month of the year
- Confirmation that spacing-out of surveys actually reduces the likelihood of finding bats.

- Low survey effort
Even if the surveyor thinks the tree can support a maternity roost, three surveys will, by an overwhelming majority, NOT FIND A BAT ROOST if one is present. Which begs the question, why bother at all?

- Assumption that buildings are more important than trees
In the 3rd Edition of the guidelines, trees received less survey effort than buildings – perhaps suggesting that the authors thought they were less important. This long standing preference towards buildings not only continues in the 4th Edition but is exacerbated.

Where were the trees experts?
All in, these new guidelines feel like a backwards step. Since the publication of the 3rd edition of the guidance in 2016, our collective knowledge of tree roosts has vastly improved. This has largely been as a result of the hard work by a network of tree climbing ecologists & arborists and the work of the Bat Tree Habitat Key Project. However, the expertise of these individuals has largely been ignored; there is a conspicuous absence of tree expertise on the technical review board, convened by the Bat Conservation Trust.
The result is, well, confusion or perhaps despair. Instead of the guidance taking us by the hand with reassuring words of advice “OK, we know this topic is tough but we’ve got your back”. The guidance instead acknowledges the challenges, then takes a few steps back with a “we’ll leave you to your own devices” approach.

A way forward
I recently published a video explaining how to use a Pivot Table to interrogate the Bat Tree Habitat Key database. I have appreciated the feedback people have provided. This can be split into two main camps:
- Positive – if you have been motivated to give it a go, I would love to hear what you think.
- Uncertain or constructively critical – this feedback centred on i) absence of records and ii) the standardisation of the data. I would love to discuss this in more detail.
To provide an opportunity to continue this discussion, I will be hosting a LinkedIn Live on Friday 30th August at 1pm. Sean from Arbology will be joining me and we would love to see you there.


Comments
Your assessment of the guidelines is spot, current survey effort and approach is abysmal & the phrase “soft felling” is ludicrous
Great! At last someone who is stating some of the obvious flaws with the ‘guidelines’ From my own discussions with NatureScot Licensing they are fully aware of the shortcomings of the current survey methodology and guidelines. They would like sites surveyed every month (during the active season at least) but they say no client is ever going to pay for that level of survey effort.
There are so many flaws in the guidelines that Ive written 5 pages of justifications for deviations that I have to resort to using now and again when submitting reports to planning when i know they will be critical of deviations. One major problem is that the environmental teams in some local authorities dont have the relevant experience in either bat ecology or survey so are making their comments purely by reference to the guidelines only and are very inflexible. Sometimes its not possible to spread surveys over a six + week period to fit in three surveys. Ive tried to point out that only the guidelines have changed bats are still doing what they have always done. How many thousands of bat reports sent to planning contain findings from a dusk and dawn 12 hours apart, or 24 hours apart, or a week or two weeks apart. Now we are at three weeks apart but the bats still do the same things they always did. We all know bats move a lot, even during daylight roosts shift so theres never any certainty non breeding roosts (or even some breeding roosts) will still be there weeks later. NatureScot would like to see surveys focus on the core maternity season so that maternity roosts are not missed obviously they are key to the species survival but its worrying that the non-breeding roosts especially spring and autumn transitional, swarming sites or hibernation roosts are not really being protected the same by this restrictive thinking. The guidelines have effectively chopped the survey season down by two months – its not only a loss of work but a loss of data. Weve found many roosts in April and October years ago and that information was valid and useful and appropriate. I think it worrying that the revision of the guidelines now means that PRF I trees are dismissed – stick up a box if you have to cut it down……. We still stick to several non-current specs for surveys. We still start 30 minutes before sunset having had roosts start to emerge as much as 29 minutes before sunset, in wooded areas we also finish surveys later at dawn having had bats return to roost 25 minutes after sunrise. We still do some limited pre-dawn survey work where we feel its appropriate. The guidelines are just that guidance but theres far too much reliance on them by the people who critique our work or who are anti-development. On a final note. My hairs still stand on end remembering when I phoned NatureScot licensing one day for some discussion on ivy-clad trees on a site and she confidently told me ‘Dont worry bats dont roost in trees’…… I paused for breath, politely thanked her for her help and hung up.
Cheers
Hi Paul,
Sounds like we have similar frustrations.
I recently heard a rumour that the Bat Conservation Trust are planning to update their tree chapter. I wait with bated breath…..
BATS R&T